Video Feedback And Learner Response

Teacher Feedback -
Great Choice of music - but I agree with your own reflection that you have ended up with two parallel montages rather than anything contrapuntal.
Good Selection of clips for both parallel montages - clear effect on the audience which is great.
Be careful with shots of a character speaking with different media - unless this is deliberate.
What clips could have been genuinely contrapuntal to this music?

Student Feedback -
WWW: The Contrapuntal sound is immediately recognisable.
             Parallel also immediately recognisable I think you did it perfectly.
EBI: No EBI except for your abrupt ending

WWW: There was a clear difference between contrapuntal and parallel.
EBI: The contrapuntal part seemed quite parallel so more could have been another choice of music.

WWW: Range of videos for the parallel part.
EBI: I was a bit confused at first because it wasn't that clear if it was contrapuntal or parallel because the music used matched some bits of that scene.

WWW: You can tell where parallel and the contrapuntal sound is and there was a smooth transition.
EBI: Although you had an idea that the first clip was contrapuntal, it was only obvious once it switched to the parallel sound.

WWW: The music was in sync with the video
EBI: The contrapuntal sound part seemed parallel.

WWW: The horror clips fits very well with the eerie music.
             Very good examples of parallel sound.
EBI: Need to apply more examples of contrapuntal music.

WWW: I liked the timing of the horror scene with the music, it gave me chills.
EBI: I couldn't really tell what was parallel and what was contrapuntal.

WWW: The timing and editing of the video was correct and well placed
EBI: Needs to be more obvious has to which was parallel and contrapuntal

WWW: Good choice of music and clips
EBI: The was a more clear difference between the two clips and the change between by adding a different sound track.



My Feedback -
WWW: The choice of music and parallel sound was quite well chosen
The editing was done quite well and on point.
EBI: However the contrapuntal sound and clips was too similar to each other causing some confusion between the clips and sound. And use better effects to show the ending and therefore making it not as much abrupt ending.

LR:

I think the best video of the class was Krissah, Annya, Harkirans video as it had two distinguishable set of scene that conveyed that they were either contrapuntal or parallel. Also the editing of his scenes was great especially the second scene as the clips had super accurate relations to the music even if it was contrapuntal.

I should focus more on the choice of clips that I did as the music does not suit the contrapuntal sound. Also to improve I should add more clips and as they had an array of clips from a similar genre that would fit the parallel and contrapuntal sound.